MESA Boston 2016 - Five Hundred Mob-Sexual Assaults and one FGM case: Whose laws rule Women’s rights in Egypt?

This document presents a note for circulation on sexual assaults and FGM-whose laws rule Women’s in Egypt. This presentation briefly exposes the challenges that Human Rights and Feminist activists endure when litigating cases that fall under the realm of Women’s Rights. This is a domain historically very politicised and a field of contestation between independent activists and state feminists.

The evolution of civil society and the rule of law regarding female genital mutilation in Iraqi Kurdistan

This document presents a study on evolution of civil society and the rule of law regarding female genital mutilation in Iraqi Kurdistan. This research evaluates the development of the rule of law, and its effectiveness, regarding female genital mutilation (FGM) as a case study in Iraqi Kurdistan from the end of the Iran-Iraq War in 1988 until 2013, the early years of the Kurdistan Regional Government’s parliament. Comprehensive rule of law evolution can be measured through comparing domestic legal developments through state-centric policy and enforcement, or lack thereof, with cultural internalization and non-governmental engagements. By studying the legal and cultural realms’ interaction with the anti-FGM discourse over Iraqi Kurdistan’s past two decades, this research will determine the role of a continuous society overlaid by intermittent legal structures in the sustainability of negotiating cultural relativity with universal human rights.

It is only a tradition: making sense of Swedish Somalis’ narratives of female circumcision and avoiding submission to hegemonic political discourse

This document presents a paper on Swedish Somalis’ narratives of female circumcision and avoiding submission to hegemonic political discourse-it’s only a tradition: making sens. This paper discusses the perspective and conclusions of an article in Critical Social Policy: ‘“It’s only a tradition”: making sense of eradication interventions and the persistence of female “circumcision” within a Swedish context’ (Ahlberg et al., 2004). In their analysis of Swedish Somalis’ narratives of female circumcision, the authors interpret the unwillingness of the interviewees to admit a persistence of tradition in terms of ‘denial’ and ‘avoidance’. The authors of this paper argue that an inadequate starting point makes their analysis biased, resulting in a violation of the interviewees’ point of view. There is a lack of contextualization and triangulation. Instead of persistence of tradition, as emphasized by Ahlberg et al., he see reasons to focus on processes of abandonment of the practice. Their article raises issues of the researcher’s position in a politicized context and of the importance of an awareness of how their preconceptions, as researchers, are formed by hegemonic political discourse

Learning from ‘‘Female Genital Mutilation’’: Lessons from 30 Years of Academic Discourse

This document presents a paper on Learning from ‘‘Female Genital Mutilation’’: Lessons from 30 Years of Academic Discourse. At the intersection of feminism and postcolonial theory is an acrimonious debate over female genital cutting (FGC). The authors subject this debate to an analysis in order to separate productive from destructive discursive strategies. The authors find that both FGC and the literature about the practice are frequently mischaracterized in consequential ways. Especially prior to the mid-1990s, scholars frame FGC as an example of either cultural inferiority or cultural difference. In the 1990s, postcolonial scholars contest the framing of FGC as a measure of cultural inferiority. However, they often argue that Western feminist engagement with FGCs, writ large, is ‘imperialist’. The authors contend that both accusations of African ‘barbarism’ and of Western feminist ‘imperialism’ are empirically false and inflammatory. Furthermore, reifying ‘African’ and ‘Western’ perspectives erases African opposition to FGC and Western feminist acknowledgement of transnational power asymmetry. The authors conclude with a discussion of the role of outrage in academic scholarship.

Long term health consequences of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)

This document presents a paper on long term of health consequences of femal genital mutilation (FGM). FGM comprises various procedures which remove or damage the external female genital organs for no medical reason. FGM has no health benefits and is recognised to cause severe short and long-term damage to both physical and psychological health. Although FGM is primarily performed in Africa, Asia and the Middle East, migration of FGM practising communities means that the health complications of FGM will have a global impact. It is important that health professionals worldwide are aware of the damage FGM causes to long term health. In some cases, it may be possible to offer interventions that will alleviate or improve symptoms. However, whilst there is some high-quality research on FGM and pregnancy outcomes, little is known about the effects on gynaecological, psychological and sexual function. Research is hampered by the problems of data collection on such a sensitive topic as well as the practical difficulties of analysis of studies based mainly on retrospect recall. Well planned hospital based studies of the impact of FGM on physical and psychological health are urgently need but are currently absent from the medical literature. Such studies could generate robust evidence to allow clinicians to benchmark clinical effectiveness and high quality medical care for survivors of FGM.

موضوع فرعي :(0)